Title: Analysis Author: Frances Hartman E-mail: fhartman1@rcn.com Spoilers: None Timeline: Somewhere in Season 7 Rating: PG Category: SR Keywords: Angst, MSR Summary: Mulder is distressed to discover that once the truth got out there, all he wanted to do was run like hell. Disclaimer: The characters of Mulder and Scully as they appear on "The X-Files" are the sole property of Chris Carter, Fox Broadcasting, and 1013 Productions, and no profit is intended or expected from this work. After reading, fold in two egg whites, whisk briefly, and let stand for an hour. Serve chilled. Thanks: To Donnilee, who kicked me in the butt and told me it was fine, and I should stop worrying about the ending; to Satina, who has been enormously patient and not given up on me completely, as well as being the best page hostess a gal could ask for; and to Sdani, who likes to poke me with sharp, pointy objects when I take time off from writing. I wanna be Porthos...the rest of y'all can fight over the other Musketeers. ********** "The strength of women comes from the fact that psychology cannot explain them. Men can be analyzed, women...merely adored." --Oscar Wilde "You still haven't told me why you're here." Mulder laughed dryly. "I would, if I knew that myself." He sighed and dragged a hand through his hair. "I can start with the obvious. I'm...having trouble with my partner." He paused, then chuckled again. "Trouble. It's such a boring word, but I don't have a better one. I think...well, I don't know if I can work with her anymore." "So why not ask for a transfer?" He shook his head. "I can't do that. The X- Files...this is my project. My baby. I can't just leave it. Besides, I don't exactly play well with others. I don't know another division that I could be as happy in. Certainly no other division would give me the autonomy and freedom to pursue my own interests as this one does." "You're the senior partner. You could have her transferred out instead, if you don't want to leave your assignment." "That hardly seems fair. I mean, the problem's mine, not hers. Seems to me that I should be the one to deal with it." "And you would be, if you had her reassigned." He said nothing. "What's the real reason you won't transfer her, Mulder?" "She's...you have to understand. Before Scully, I went through partners like most people go through Kleenex. I've been with her for seven years. The last thing I want to do is break in another partner. Scully's comfortable. We're used to each other." "Not that comfortable if you think you can't work with her anymore." "That's not..." He broke off in exasperation. "All right. That's not it, exactly. But it's part of it. I just..." "Just...?" There was no response. "Okay, Mulder. Let me ask you something. If you couldn't work with other people before, what makes Scully so different?" He cracked a smile. "Well, she's female, for one thing." "And that makes her easier to work with?" That startled a laugh out of him. "Not at all. I never had to worry about being the PMS poster boy before. It's a whole new set of challenges." His smile faded. "No, Scully is...see, it's hard being the Bureau wing nut. It would be easier if I didn't realize how crazy I sounded sometimes. But I know it. And so does she. But no matter how far out on a limb I go, she's right there." He grinned fleetingly. "Usually with a saw." "So she doesn't usually agree with your theories?" "Not usually? Try hardly ever. And that's the point, I think. Most people...well, they just look at me like I'm a few curds short of a cheese curl and walk away. Scully sticks around and argues with me." He shook his head. "That's amazing. She actually thinks about these things and works them through. Sure, she puts 'em through the meat grinder of her logic, but that's what's so great. She takes me seriously enough to bother trying to poke holes in my theories. Which, in turn, makes me work even harder." "So what are you saying, that she brings you credibility in the Bureau?" "Not really." He gestured helplessly. "I'm not sure anything could do that. The things I deal with, they're too strange, too obscure, and usually too disturbing for anyone to want to examine closely enough to lend credence to them. You have to work with them day in and day out like we do for that to happen. And I've invested too much energy in trying to fuck with people to care what they think." "But you care what she thinks." Mulder paused for a moment, turning that over in his mind. "You know, not really," he said with some surprise. "It's just that when I know I'm going to have to run them past her...I have to make sure I've got something concrete to back my ideas up, even though it might not match the outside world's definition of concrete. We follow different rules of evidence, of investigation...hell, even of nature, sometimes...in the X-Files. I hadn't realized before how lazy that made me." He shrugged. "She gives me credibility with myself, I guess you could say." "But now you know. Couldn't you police yourself, if she left?" He shrugged. "I guess. But it wouldn't be the same." "What if they gave you another partner with a scientific background?" Mulder chuckled. "That would be deadly. I'd have to jump through hoops all over again. But even if they could find someone like that...it still wouldn't be the same. It wouldn't be Scully. We have a history together. We understand each other. We trust each other." "Couldn't you learn to trust someone else?" He laughed shortly. "Unlikely." "That's hard for you." "You could say that, yeah." "But you trust Scully." "I do. Almost from the beginning, I trusted her. It was strange...I mean, I know why she was assigned to work with me. In my paranoid moments, I figured she was sent to spy on me...to keep me from uncovering the truth. In my more rational moments, I thought at best, she was sent to debunk my project...to prove the scientific invalidity of my life's work. Either way, I was fully prepared to be on my guard from point one. "But on our very first case, something happened. I'm not exactly sure what it was, but I realized Scully had integrity. It didn't matter what the powers that be had in mind for her; she was going to do her damndest to solve each case, no matter what it took. She gave me hell, but it wasn't because of anyone else's agenda. It was because she wanted the truth as much as I did...she just had a different way of going about it. And in all this time, with everything we've seen and been through together, that's never changed. The one thing I can depend on, no matter what else has been thrown at me or taken away from me, is Scully herself. Still there, still honest, still backing me up. Even when she thinks I'm full of shit, she backs me. She might not believe me sometimes, but she always believes *in* me." He shrugged. "She knows what makes me tick, and she sticks around anyway, but she never uses it against me. If that's not trust, I don't know what is. What are the odds I'm going to find that with anyone else?" "It sounds like she's pretty important to you." "Yeah. Scully's not only my partner, she's my best friend...maybe my only real friend. And when we're working together, it's like...I don't know. Like we're two halves of a whole, somehow. It's not something we plan, we just complement each other perfectly. Half the time, she knows what I'm thinking before I do. And the reverse is true too, but..." He smiled ruefully. "But she still manages to surprise me. Keeps me coming back." "Mulder. Are you listening to yourself? It's pretty clear that you don't want her to leave. You still want to keep working with her." He took a deep breath and then released it. "Yeah. Yeah, I do." "Okay, then. If you don't want her to leave, and you feel you *can't* leave...what's the alternative? You've got to try to work out whatever the problem is." He sighed heavily. "I guess that's true," he said reluctantly. "Can you try to put it into words? The problem?" He gave a dry smile. "I can try." Restlessly, Mulder got up to pace, and for long minutes, there was no sound in the room but footfalls on the carpet. Finally, he came to a stop. "I think I'm in love with her," he blurted. The words hung in the air for a moment. "Ah." "It's kind of hard to tell, you understand. I'm not entirely certain I've ever been in love before. There have been times I thought I was, but..." He shuddered in remembrance. "I don't know. Call me a helpless romantic, but I think there's supposed to be at least a nanosecond of happiness associated with the thought of your partner, if that's the case." "Usually, yes. And does thinking of Scully make you happy?" "I guess it depends on how I'm thinking about her. You mean when I'm thinking about the next great way someone's going to hurt her to get at me? No. You mean when I'm thinking about how much her partnership with me has cost her personally? No. You mean when I'm thinking about how I'm indirectly responsible for the deaths of her sister and her daughter? No. You mean when I'm thinking about the look on her face when she sees other people with homes, families, normal lives, and I realize she could have had all that, if it weren't for me? Not particularly, no." He closed his eyes for a moment. "And if you mean when I look into her eyes and realize that her innocence is all but gone, and I'm the one who took it away from her?" A muscle jumped in his jaw. "No. No, it doesn't make me happy. Not one damned bit." "Wow. That's quite a load of guilt you bear, Mulder." "Well deserved, I assure you." "And are those the only things you think about when Scully comes to mind?" "No," he allowed with a self-deprecating smile. "No, that's not all I think about." "And these other thoughts...do they make you happy?" "Sometimes." Mulder's gaze turned inward as he explored some private vision. "And when are you happy?" "Sometimes...when I think about what it might have been like if we'd met in another place, another time," he said quietly. "If we could have that normal life I know she wants. I guess I want it too, or I wouldn't think about it so much." His eyes were unfocused, and a small smile curved his generous lips. "I think about making her coffee on Sunday mornings, or waking up with her in my arms, or sometimes just being able to hold her hand. I think about things like cooking dinner with her, or painting the kitchen, or taking turns walking the baby, trying to get him to fall asleep." He blinked, and the curious blankness of expression returned to his eyes, masking the tenderness that had been so apparent the moment before. "And that's usually about the point in the fantasy where I stop being quite so happy." He shook his head. "Scully can't have any children," he said after a moment. "And that's a result of her work with me, as well." "And is that the deal breaker for you, Mulder? The fact that she can't have children?" "Of course not!" Mulder was indignant. "That doesn't matter to me, except for how it hurts her. If all I wanted was to perpetuate my genes, we wouldn't be having this discussion." "Mm. But the scenario you were describing... it led you there anyway. So if it isn't about the children...if it isn't her infertility itself that snaps you out of the fantasy, it must be the guilt." Mulder was silent. "You're more at home with your guilt than your happiness, at least where Scully's concerned. Would you say that's a fair assessment?" He paused, clearly taken aback. "No...I mean, I don't think so..." He trailed off, assessing the implications. "Well, it is the first thing you brought up when I asked you if thinking about her makes you happy. Your guilt. Did you realize that?" He chewed on his lip for a moment. "I don't know...I mean, I've never thought about it as guilt, exactly. More like responsibility." He studied his fingertips intently, working it out. "So many times, I've been tempted to walk away. But I can't stand not knowing. I can't stand the idea that they'll get away with it all. But it's strange. Every time I feel myself getting tired, like I need to rest...Scully will say something to me that turns it all around for me." "You mean she encourages you to keep going?" He gave a harsh bark of laughter. "Not at all. I could share the responsibility if that were the case, you see. But this one's all me. "No, she says something like, 'Don't you ever want a normal life, Mulder?' Or maybe, 'Don't you ever want to just get out of the car, Mulder?' Or how about my personal favorite...'Maybe you should ask yourself if your heart's still in it, too.' "And then the strangest thing happens. The second she says those things...it's like I suddenly realize I have no choice. Maybe...I don't know...maybe it's just realizing that if I don't do this, no one will. And it needs to be done. Right when she says those things...it...well, it shames me, somehow. Like she knows what I'm thinking and she's telling me that if I quit, I shouldn't be expecting her to carry on. But if *I* stay, *she* will." He rubbed his eyes tiredly. "So I can't share the responsibility. Every time she tells me she wants to stop, it just makes me want to keep going. How selfish does that make me?" The question hung in the air for long moments. "Well. That was a loaded statement." He quirked an eyebrow. "Loaded in what way?" "Well, let's take things one at a time. Are you expecting her to carry on?" "That's a tough one." Mulder rubbed a hand across his chin. "Expecting it, no. I wouldn't expect her to do something I wouldn't do myself." "You say that like she'd have no reason of her own to see this through. And if what you tell me is true, about what this search has cost her, don't you think she'd have reason?" He faltered for a moment. "I...I suppose that's true. I guess I've never really thought of it that way. But either way, I don't expect it of her, exactly." He exhaled sharply. "Or maybe I do. It's more accurate to say that I would never think less of her if she didn't. It's just that, knowing her the way I do, I more or less assume that she would." "But you just said that you never considered that this quest would have personal relevance for her. If that's the case, why would you think she'd carry on regardless?" "Because..." Mulder broke off sharply, aghast at the turn his thoughts had taken. "I don't think I want to answer that right now." "Okay, we'll come back to that. You said that she seems to be implying that if you quit, so will she. Is that her talking, or you?" He arched an eyebrow. "Meaning?" "You're the one with the eidetic memory, Mulder. You tell me. Think back to those things she said to you, the ones you just told me, and repeat them back to me. One at a time." He shrugged. "Don't you ever want a normal life, Mulder?" "Don't you?" "I think I just said that, didn't I?" "Okay, question answered. What's the next one?" "Don't you ever just want to get out of the car, Mulder?" "And do you?" His answer was quieter this time. "Yeah. Yeah, I do." "And..." "Maybe you should ask yourself if your heart's still in it, too." The words were a barely audible whisper. "Have you asked yourself that question, Mulder?" "No. It's been my life for so long, I can't imagine..." There was a flash of naked fear behind his hazel eyes before he quickly resumed a neutral expression. "I can't, not yet." "You said earlier that Scully often seems to know what you're thinking even before you do. I have to be honest with you, Mulder. I'm not hearing any censure in the things she's saying to you. What I'm hearing is the genuine concern of someone who knows you very well and cares about you." "So you're saying that she wants me to stop." "Not exactly, no. I think that maybe she senses that you do. Tell me something. If you did...stop, that is...would Scully think less of you, do you think?" "No...well, maybe." He frowned. "I don't know what she'd think, actually." "Have you considered the possibility that this is her way of telling you that it's okay?" He shook his head emphatically. "No. You can't hear her voice when she says these things. I can. She's tired. It's not just in her voice, it's in her eyes, the way she moves..." "So why doesn't she? In your opinion." "Because..." Once again, Mulder stopped himself in mid-sentence. "It's okay, Mulder. We'll come back to that one, too. But here's the big question." "Shoot." "Okay. Here's what we have so far; stop me when I make a mistake. You've been thinking that you're tired. You're wondering if it's time to rest...to stop running, but maybe you're not sure yet. Right so far?" "Yeah." "So you start playing with it in your mind, but whenever you do, Scully says something that makes you think better of the idea. For whatever reason. Right?" "So far, so good." "But what she says, in essence...not what you hear, mind you...is simply a confirmation that she knows what you're thinking." "I suppose that's true." "And that's not what seems to stop you...after all, she's second-guessed your thoughts before, and it's usually more comforting than frightening, isn't that correct?" "Correct." "So if I'm hearing you right, it's not what she's saying that's giving you pause. It's what you're hearing. And what you're hearing is that *she* wants to stop." "That's what I think I'm hearing, yes." "So why don't you?" "Why don't I what?" "Stop." Mulder greeted that simple question with a stunned silence. "Mulder, it's clear that you don't want to be separated from Scully. You want to stop. She wants to stop. If you did, you could be together, maybe have that normal life you fantasize about. So why haven't you? "I think the question you need to ask yourself is why the idea that Scully actually agrees with you about this frightens you so much...so much so that you simply drop the question and choose to maintain the status quo. That's not a choice; that's inertia. "But whether to stop or go on...that question is actually less important. What's significant here is that you're so easily influenced by her feelings on the subject." He raised his brows, but said nothing. "You know, I haven't turned this around for you. Would you think less of her if she got out?" "No." Mulder's response was instant and definite. "She's suffered so much...how could I possibly blame her? Frankly, the smartest thing for her to do would be to get out. The fact that she hasn't...it blows my mind. And in my more selfish moments, I'm terrifyingly grateful that she hasn't." "Why is that?" Mulder looked away quickly, chewing on his lip. "I don't want to lose her," he said in a small voice. "She's...she's too important to me." After a moment, he glanced up, a self-deprecating smile on his face. "But you know something? At the rate things are going, if she stays, I'm going to lose her anyway. Physically, maybe, if one of these times, one of us is a bit too slow. Emotionally, probably. I think being with me is killing her inside." "But she doesn't leave you. Not even to protect herself." He didn't respond. "Are you punishing her for something, Mulder?" "What?" His eyes widened in disbelief. "Are you punishing her? You think you know she'll stay if you do. You think you know she wants to leave, somewhere deep inside. And when you think you hear her telling you these things, it just makes you want to keep going, sometimes when even you want to stop. You think this persistence is hurting her, and she's making no effort to protect herself against it. If you're taking responsibility for causing that pain...and I'm not saying that's appropriate, mind you, just restating what you've told me...you also then could take responsibility for stopping that pain. And yet, when I suggested transferring her out before, you flatly refused. What's going on here, Mulder?" He was silent for long, long minutes, processing this in his mind. "It's not her I'm punishing," he admitted at last. "I think it's me." "Being with Scully is a punishment?" "Not...not exactly. I think," he said slowly, "that I'm doing penance." "For the sins we talked about earlier?" "Yeah. She's given up so much..." he swallowed hard, "...for me," he finished quietly. "The road to Hell and all that...she's followed me more times than I can count. I can't give back her fertility or her innocence or the years she's lost, but maybe I can give her some sense of closure. She deserves to know why. If it were just me, I don't think...I think it would have been over for me long ago, one way or the other. But after all she's sacrificed, I can't devalue that by giving up so easily. I can't come to her with that on my conscience, along with everything else." "Does Scully blame you for these things?" He looked up with bleak eyes. "I honestly don't know. I can't see past blaming myself." "Have you asked her?" There was just the slightest trace of a sardonic smile on his lips as he answered. "I do believe that is what is known as a rhetorical question." "Is it? You told me that Scully was a woman of integrity, that she was always honest with you. Don't you think her honesty would extend to this?" "I don't know. I hope so, but..." "But?" "I know that Scully wouldn't want to hurt me," he said. "She's a woman of integrity, but also of great compassion. It's one thing to think she ought to blame me," he confessed painfully. "It's another thing to actually hear her say it out loud. And I think she knows that." "It sounds like you've already decided that she does blame you." He shook his head sadly. "Not really. I...I don't think I know what would be worse; hearing that she does blame me, or that she doesn't." He sighed. "She probably should, if she has any sense, but I don't think she would. She has a tendency to take an awful lot of responsibility for things that are beyond her control." "Sounds like you two have a lot in common." Mulder's head jerked up, but he remained silent. "Mulder, here's what else I'm hearing. I'm hearing that you think there are two different Scullys. There's the one you described at the beginning of our session...she's strong, self-assured, and confident. She stands up for herself and lets you have it if you step over the line, but isn't afraid to stick her neck out and back you up. She's loyal, honest, and straightforward. Sounds like a pretty tough lady." He smiled. "Yeah. Yeah, she is." "Right. Well, then there's the other Scully. This one I can't quite figure out. She's a victim, rather than a survivor. She's secretive, rather than direct. She holds grudges. She's a martyr. She's willing to sublimate her personality for you and your whims, for some private agenda that she's not sharing with you. Doesn't sound like someone that should scare you so much." "She doesn't...I mean, that's not what she's like at all. Where did you get that from?" "From you, Mulder. I think I understand where most of your fears come from, but you have to realize that you're projecting them onto Scully, onto what your guilt tells you her reactions ought to be. And that brings us back to those things we passed on earlier." Mulder took a deep breath. "I figured that was coming." "It's truth time, Mulder. Why hasn't Scully left you long ago? I'm sure you've asked yourself that question before; let's finally answer it. Why?" "I...I don't know. I've thought about it and thought about it, but..." "Don't think, Mulder. From the gut. You're the one who knows her so well. She's pretty tough, but even so, hanging in there all this time with everything she's gone through is asking a lot. So why?" "I think..." "Don't think." His mouth worked soundlessly for long moments. "You know the answer already, Mulder. Just say it." "But I don't..." "You do. Just say it." "She..." He faltered for a moment. "She what, Mulder?" "She...she..." He drew a deep, shuddering breath. "She loves me," he whispered brokenly. "Why is that so hard to admit?" "Because...I...Jesus," he muttered, running a hand through his hair. "You knew that. That's how you knew she would carry on your quest, and how you knew she wouldn't leave as long as you continued. She loves you. How long have you known this?" "I...for a while now," he admitted. "Since...well, I've suspected it for a while, but over the past year or two, it...well, I knew. I just...try not to think about it." "Why not?" "I'm not sure..." "You need to stop hiding, Mulder. You've got to get this all out in the open, even if it's only to me. Why are you so afraid of her loving you?" "Because she deserves better!" The words exploded from him. "If I...if we were to..." He sucked in a breath. "If I face the fact that she loves me...and I love her...what's the next step? Every day of my life, I face the fact that I've dragged her down into the darkness with me. I can't ask her to live with that, too. I've already ruined so much of her life, don't you think she deserves better than my ruining the rest of it, too?" "Does she?" His eyes narrowed. "What's that supposed to mean?" he asked belligerently. "Mulder, listen to yourself. If you're really the man you describe to me, what does it say about her judgment that she fell in love with you? Maybe she deserves you." His mouth fell open in shock. "I don't believe you just said that. Scully is..." "Is what, Mulder? Strong, independent, and capable of making her own decisions? Intelligent, loyal and caring? Of sound mind, good character, and deserving of the best life has to offer?" "Yes." "And she chose you, Mulder. *You.* No one else. If she's really the woman you describe to me, she could have chosen anyone she wanted. She's thirty-five, Mulder. I'm sure she's had the opportunity, no matter how busy you keep her. And she chose *you.* "Which Scully is she, Mulder? The strong or the weak?" "The strong," he whispered, mind whirling. "The victim or the survivor?" "The survivor." "The heroine or the martyr?" "The heroine," he responded quietly. "If that's what you believe, what does that say about you, Mulder...the man she chose?" "I..." "Does it say that maybe, just maybe, she does deserve you?" "I...I can't." Tears were pricking at his eyes. "If we tried this...I couldn't handle it. Eventually, she'd come to hate me...I couldn't take that. As it is now, I still have my dreams." "But you could have them. You could be living them, Mulder. All you have to do is reach for them." "Dreams don't last," he said with a touch of bitterness. "Not once daylight hits them." "Why are you so sure of that? What makes you think that her love would turn to hate, if it hasn't already?" "Because she doesn't...I mean...she doesn't know..." He trailed off, unable to complete the thought. "Because she doesn't know the real you. And if she did, she wouldn't love you anymore." There was a shocked silence, and then, to their mutual surprise, Mulder suddenly burst out laughing. "I always knew I'd eventually be reduced to a cliche." ***************** "Mulder, why are you sitting here in the dark?" He looked up in surprise, only then realizing that the shadows that had just begun to stretch across the floor of his apartment when he had come home earlier now shrouded the entire room in an inky blackness. He could barely make out the form of his partner standing just inside the door, and laughed quietly. "You know, years ago, your sister said almost those exact words to me, in just that tone of voice." Scully's lips twitched, a sad yet fond smile flirting with the corners of her mouth. "And what reason did you give her?" "That the lights weren't on." "I bet she loved that." Slowly, she crossed the room and lowered herself to sit beside him in the gloom. "Darkness, light...they were her metaphors for life," she commented after a moment. "She probably had a field day with you, telling you that you were walking in darkness." "She did. But she was right. I was, especially then." He sighed softly. "Maybe I still am." "If things had turned out differently, you probably would have become her pet project. I always wondered if..." Her voice trailed off uncertainly, and he turned to look at her. "You wondered what?" He raised an eyebrow in the darkness. "Just that..." She shrugged self- consciously. "I don't know. You and Melissa..." She looked away, suddenly glad of the shadows in the room that masked her sudden blush. "Ah." He pondered for a moment, then shook his head. "I don't think so. Two flakes...I think we'd have driven each other nuts...if we survived the first dose of reality." He shook his head in exasperation. "Do you really think that's what I want in a woman?" "Mulder!" She was outraged. "You may be crazy, but you're not a flake." He blinked. "Scully, that statement doesn't even make sense. And what, are you saying your sister was?" She faltered a moment. "I...well, maybe a bit. And anyway, I don't think I ever really thought about it in terms of whether you'd be attracted to her. I just knew that she'd be attracted to you. You were...are...exactly what got her going." "That being?" "Well, apart from the obvious--" "Nothing's obvious, Scully, you know that." His voice was teasing. "Nothing except your fishing for compliments, you mean." Her smile faded as she reflected. "No, Melissa took being a big sister pretty seriously. She would have been a great mother, I think. She loved taking care of people. And you would have been like a magnet for that. And she was...I don't know, I think she felt drawn to heal, in some way. On the soul level, I think. She always swore she could sense people's pain, and always felt compelled to try to banish it. I always thought that if she found the right man, she would have dedicated her life to making him happy. But at the same time, she didn't have any patience for people who would rather whine than try to help themselves. It isn't that she wanted someone to mother; I think it was more that she wanted someone who was strong enough to help her, and strong enough to let her help him." She smiled again. "Of course, she also always wanted someone smart, who could make her laugh at life, and at herself. I think because she felt other people's pain so deeply, it made her want to experience joy that much more." He was silent for long moments. "It sounds like you knew her pretty well; you know, what made her tick." He laughed hollowly. "Unlike me." "I think that's to be expected, Mulder. She wasn't just my sister, she was my friend. I knew her for her entire life. You only knew her a few months." "I didn't mean me knowing her, Scully. I meant you knowing me." She frowned. "Mulder, why *are* you sitting here in the dark? And I'm not Melissa, so there's no need to belabor the obvious." "There's that word again." He paused for a moment, gathering his thoughts. "Scully...you said Melissa wasn't just your sister, she was your friend." "Right. What's this about, Mulder? What's wrong?" He continued as if she hadn't spoken. "And I'm your partner. We haven't known each other all of our lives, but for, what, seven years? That's a pretty long time. Would you say I'm your friend?" Her brow creased. "Of course. You're my best friend, you know that." "Do I?" He shifted uncomfortably. "That's hard to believe sometimes. You don't know me at all, I think." She crossed her arms. "That's the second time you've said that, and I think I'm a bit insulted. Why on earth would you say I don't know you? I think I know you as well as anybody." "And that, my dear partner, isn't worth the paper those words are written on. No one knows me like that. Not like you knew Melissa." She opened her mouth to reply, then stopped herself. There was a wealth of sadness behind Mulder's words, and like her late sister, she suddenly felt compelled to try to ease his pain. "I think I do," she said softly. "At least, better than you think I do." She swallowed hard. "Melissa and I had a lot in common, you see." "Yeah? I get you going, Scully?" The teasing lilt was a desperate attempt to lighten the mood, but she chose to answer him seriously. "Of course you do, Mulder. Surely you knew that." For such weighted words, they were spoken in the most casual of tones, and he blinked in surprise. For the first time, one of the dangerous thoughts swirling through both of their minds had been uttered aloud. After a moment, he commanded himself to breathe again. "If I do, then that proves more than anything that you don't really know me, Scully." The undercurrent of loneliness was back, and her heart ached for him. "If you did, I...doubt I'd have quite that effect on you." "You think?" "I know." "So tell me." "Tell you what?" "What you've been hiding from me. This terrible thing that I don't know." His mouth worked for a moment. "I...anything. It isn't...I mean..." He broke off with an exasperated snort. "You don't understand, Scully. It's not something I've done or haven't done, or said or haven't said, or have or don't have. Or...I don't know. Maybe it's all those things. It's just who I am." "I think I do understand, Mulder." Carefully, she reached through the waves of tension rolling off him and rested her fingers atop his cold, clenched fist. "Why don't I tell you what I do know, okay? Stop me when I make a mistake." He blinked and tensed at the familiar words, but remained silent. She paused, gathering her thoughts. "You do get me going, Mulder," she began. "I could say that's because you're beautiful. And that would be true, but I don't think that's what you need to hear right now." She held up her hand to forestall his response. "Or what..." She faltered, then strengthened her nerve. "Or what I need to say. I think what we both need to hear is why I think that." "Scully, this isn't about--" "Sh. Please." She glanced away for a second. "This isn't easy, Mulder. But I think that..." She drew in a calming breath. "I think that these are things that need to be said. That I need to say. And maybe I'm being selfish here, because I know that something's eating you up inside right now, and my needs are the last thing you should be worrying about. But I need to talk, and I need you to listen, okay?" He stared at her in horrified fascination. How the hell did she do that? One minute, she was all prepared to give him a pep talk, and the next, she was turning into an episode of True Confessions. And he knew that the end result was going to be the same. He was going to have to sit and listen to her tell him how wonderful he was, when they both knew it was a crock of shit she was feeding him just to make him feel better. And because she had put him on the spot by telling him it was for *her*, he didn't have a choice. Curtly, he nodded once. Her lips tightened. "You know, for someone who claims I don't know them, I didn't have a single problem reading your mind just now." "Yeah, Scully? Ya think?" he mockingly parroted her earlier question. "I know," she answered in the same tone. "You're still thinking this is all about you, isn't it?" He crossed his arms defensively. "Well, isn't it? This isn't the usual 'chin up Mulder you're really an okay guy' speech?" He laughed bitterly. "Thanks, Scully, but I still have a tape recording of the last one. You don't need to go into it again. Besides, you're a crappy liar." She studied him for a moment, brow creased. "Well, if you were trying to prove that I really don't know what's going on inside your head after all, I think you've just succeeded. Now you're the one who's not making sense." She chewed on her lip for a moment. "So I'm just gonna take that at face value. Heard it all before, have you?" "Yup." "And nothing I can say will make a difference in your suitably black mood this evening, right?" "It's more of a dark gray, but yeah, I don't see what would." She nodded. "What if I say something that you haven't heard before? Not just something different, but something that would completely surprise you?" Despite his growing annoyance, Mulder was intrigued. "Give it your best shot, Scully." "Okay." Shifting to face him, she took his face between her hands. "You said I'm a lousy liar. So you should know whether what I'm about to say is the absolute truth." Cautiously, he nodded, and she stared him straight in the eyes. "I love you, Mulder. I'm head over heels, completely gone, totally and truly in love with you." He blinked slowly once, then twice. She had indeed surprised him, but not in the way that she thought she would. He blinked again. A slight frown twisted her lips. "Well, that's certainly an overwhelming response." Gently freeing himself from her grasp, he leaned back on the couch. "I'm sorry, Scully," he said quietly after a moment. "I think...I think I knew this already. But if it's any consolation, you did surprise me. I didn't think you'd actually say it." Absently, he rubbed his hand over his eyes and sighed heavily. God, he wasn't ready for this confrontation. Not yet. Maybe not ever. "I'm not sure I know what to say." "You don't have to say anything." Her voice was tight and controlled, and when he glanced up, his stomach twisted at the carefully hidden pain in her expression. Carefully hidden from anyone but him, that is. After years of knowing her, watching her, loving her, he had learned that what she didn't show spoke louder and more clearly than what she did. He had hurt her badly with his reaction, and he closed his eyes against the awful emptying pain the knowledge brought. "Oh, Scully. You don't understand, I--" "It's okay, Mulder. Really, it is." She shook her head and jumped to her feet. "I shouldn't have--" "Shouldn't have what?" He rose quickly, catching her hand when she would have fled. "Shouldn't have told me how you felt?" "Oh, lots of things." She pulled away and quickly walked to the door. "Shouldn't have told you, shouldn't have pushed you to talk...hell, I shouldn't even have come over here tonight." She grabbed her coat and yanked the door open. "I have to go." "No!" It wasn't quite a shout, but Mulder put enough emotional force behind the word that she stopped dead in her tracks. Strange, he thought wildly. A minute ago, this conversation was the last one he wanted to have. But now...he had to make this right. Forcibly, he softened his tone. "Don't go, Scully. Please." For long moments, neither of them moved, until finally, she closed the door gently and leaned against it, keeping her back to him. "What?" she whispered, the word barely audible around the lump in her throat. He froze. Now he had her, and she was listening, and he had no idea how to start. Stymied, he floundered for something to say. "Scully, do you know where I was today?" he suddenly blurted, then blanched as he realized what he'd said. What was he doing? Why was he torturing himself like this? "Does it matter, Mulder?" Her voice was tiny, but her weariness...and wariness...was apparent. Without warning, something snapped and broke inside him, and all the fight flowed out of him as he stared at her bent head. "Yeah. Yeah, it does," he said with some surprise. His expression was pensive as he studied her slight form, braced against the door as she awaited the lash of the next words out of his mouth. How did we come to this, he wondered with a touch of shame. Combatants, instead of partners? He shook his head slowly as he realized that she expected him to hurt her again; a worry which, he acknowledged painfully, was entirely justified, considering his behavior tonight. And yet she stayed. Waiting, though she was obviously convinced that he was going to throw the gift of her love back in her face again. She knew that he would hurt her, and she stayed anyway. Just like she always had. Because she loved him. Just like she always had. How many times had he put her in this position over the years? Tensely awaiting the next blow of the axe, she would stand perfectly still. Waiting for him to hurt her again. And yet she stayed. He knew she wasn't weak. Just this afternoon, hadn't he railed at the too-calm assessment of her as a martyr, as a professional victim, as an abused innocent? Scully was strong and made her own choices; if he knew anything about her, it was this. She never did anything she did not want to do. Neither he, nor circumstance, had ever made choices for her. She alone chose. And she chose...to stay. No matter how many times he had hurt her, ignored her, used her, manipulated her, or taken her for granted, she chose to stay. Just like now. Just like she always had. He stood mutely as understanding flowed over him. Just like she always would. "God, Scully," he murmured, a catch in his throat. "I don't deserve you." She turned to face him, startled by the hitch in his voice, and her mouth dropped open in surprise at the tears brimming in his eyes. "Mulder..." she broke off in bewilderment, her tongue slicking over her lips nervously as he slowly crossed to stand before her. Instinctively, she pressed her back against the door, seeking some reassurance, some support. He swallowed hard at the self- protective gesture. "Mulder, you don't need to say things like that. If you don't feel--" "It's true, Scully. I don't. Deserve you, that is. I never have." Never breaking their locked stare, he slowly sank to his knees in front of her as she regarded him in amazement. "But I will," he vowed, sliding his arms about her waist and burying his head in her stomach. "Before God, I swear I will." The words were muffled against her midriff, but Scully heard. Stunned, she raised a shaking hand to brush his hair back off his forehead. "Mulder..." The word emerged on a strangled sob, and she quickly cleared her throat and said the first thing that came into her mind. "Mulder, tell me where you were today." His arms tightened about her for a moment before he sat back on his heels and gazed at the floor, looking for all the world like a penitent making obeisance at the foot of an idol. "I went to see one of the EAP counselors today. About us," he confessed softly. "I told him that I didn't think we could work together anymore." After a moment, he shook his head. "No, that's not quite right. I told him I didn't think I could work with you anymore." She swayed slightly. "Because you knew how I felt," she replied tightly. "I can understand that." "No! I didn't mean--" Sighing, he looked away. "I'm not saying this well, Scully. Like you said, it isn't easy. But you were right when you said that it needs to be said, and heard." Painfully, he pulled himself to his feet, never releasing his grip on her. "Listen. Just listen," he whispered. "Please. I promise it'll be okay." After a moment, she nodded and allowed him to lead her back to the couch. Sitting beside her, he took her cold hands in his. "I didn't know why I was having trouble, but it became pretty clear what the problem was before very long. At least a big part of it." He swallowed hard and stared at their clasped hands. "I told him...and believe me, I was as surprised as he was when these words came out of me...I told him that I was in love with you." She inhaled sharply, shock and amazement painting her delicate features. "Oh," she said finally. "Yeah, that's pretty much what he said." He shook his head in wonderment. "And that should have been the end of it, at least at that point. I mean, if I realized I loved you..." He trailed off and shrugged self- consciously. "But of course, I had to make it more complicated than that." "Oh, Mulder." She touched his cheek. "But you knew how I felt. You couldn't possibly have believed I'd reject you. Could you?" He remained silent. "You did, didn't you? But why?" "Like I said, it's more complicated than that." Dropping his head back on the couch, he gazed at the ceiling. "It took me forever to admit that I did know...how you felt. I just didn't want to believe it. And I wanted to believe it more than anything you could imagine. It's just that reconciling those two feelings...sucked. And that's what I was trying to do, sitting here in the dark." "And then I barged in here." Scully bit her lip. "I'm sorry." "Don't be. I don't think I could have done it if you hadn't come over. Or maybe I could have, but it wouldn't have turned out the way it should have." He glanced over at her, his heart contracting at the taut expression on her face. "Hey," he murmured, touching her cheek. "I told you it would be okay. Just listen." He exhaled heavily, letting his hand fall from her face. "I was scared to death. Still am, you know. But I think I can deal with it now." Idly, he began tracing patterns on the back of her hand with his thumb. "It took everything I had to actually say it out loud...that I thought you loved me. It terrified me. It paralyzed me. All I could think was that I'd been in this holding pattern for God knows how long, and I could do that because as long as I didn't *say* it, it wasn't real. But now it was out there, and I had to actually do something." He smiled briefly. "Isn't that great? The truth was out there, at last. And all I wanted to do was run like hell. "Don't get me wrong, Scully. I didn't want to run away from you...this...us. Not exactly. It's just..." He shook his head again. "God, I don't know how to say this without hurting you even more. And it isn't something that should hurt you. I just don't have the right words, and I'm afraid that--" "Mulder." She stopped him with a gentle hand on his lips. Looking up, he started at the open tenderness on her face. "I've been jumping to conclusions all night, and all it's done is make you scared to say anything. I'm sorry." She gave him a sad smile. "No, I really am. God knows, I've wanted you to talk to me...really talk to me...for what seems like forever. The last thing I wanted to do was tie you up in knots so badly that you couldn't tell me truth, no matter what it is. You just talk, and I'll just listen. I promise." She squeezed his hand lightly. "We'll deal with everything else later. Tell me what scared you so much. What made you want to run away." He brushed a soft kiss over her fingertips before recapturing her hand in his. "I do love you, Scully," he said after a moment. "Despite how it might appear. Even with everything I've done to you, to hurt you, I do love you." He was pensive as he stared into the gathering shadows. "Time heals all wounds, they say. And I suppose that's true, but it also creates new ones. And you know, no matter how much I might want to be half of a whole, that desperation doesn't guarantee I'll know how to do it when the time comes. It isn't something that I've ever been able to pull off successfully. And the more time marches on, the more uncertain I am of my ability to acquire that particular skill." He chuckled. "It's too bad you can't practice without really hurting someone in the process. Yourself, usually. "It's funny. I knew a girl once who waited until she was twenty-five to have sex... saving herself for marriage, she said, but she got tired of waiting. Only problem was that people had been filling her head for years with the idea that it was going to hurt the first time. And when the time came, she couldn't enjoy herself at all, because she was so busy waiting for the pain. I can relate." He shrugged. "I'm not sure who would have more of a field day with me, Roosevelt or Freud. I can't figure out what scares me more, the pain, or the fear itself." True to her promise, Scully said nothing, but inside, she was seething with a million emotions. She was quaking with terror. She was sick with anxiety. She was aching with tenderness. But most of all, she was overwhelmed by the desire to take him in her arms and convince him somehow, some way, that the pain he expected was far from predestined. He doesn't know that I'd die before I'd hurt him, she thought in realization. The trick is to make him believe it. But for now, she simply listened. "It's so hard to shake the idea that if you knew me, really knew me, you wouldn't love me," he said after a moment. "I mean, sure, of course you do, on a certain level. But the inner me...the blood and guts of my somewhat twisted psyche...I've kept that hidden from you. And if I face this...what's between us...I can't keep hiding. And the more I thought about it, I mean...I don't know what frightened me more, that you might leave, or that you might stay." "But--" "You don't know what I've done, Scully. Who I am...what I'm capable of. It scares me, and I have to live with me. How could I ask you to accept it if I can't accept it in myself? I see it on your face sometimes, you know. The horrified fascination when you catch stray glimpses of the demons that drive me. Sort of like staring at a fatal car crash, isn't it?" "Mulder..." "Still, I can't help myself." In agitation, he got to his feet and paced restlessly. "There's something about you that seems to...I don't know, purify me, is the best way I can put it...and sometimes, the compulsion to reveal those darker sides of myself to you is almost overwhelming." He spread his hands helplessly. "I only wish I could be sure that the compulsion is from a need to heal myself, and not some sick desire to drag you down into the darkness with me. All I know is that when I open the door to that place, a part of me lightens and becomes free, until the moment I realize what I've done. And then the only thing I can do is slam the door shut again and run like hell, wondering if this is the time that I've gone too far. Wandered too close to the truth." He snorted in self-deprecation. "Listen to me. I'm a fucking poet." He thrust his hands in his pockets and turned to face the window, staring out unseeingly. "But this is the weird thing. No matter how far or fast I run, you're always there on the other side. Waiting. And oddly enough, it's at that point that I'm most confused. I can't decide whether I want to scream at you to get the hell away from me before it's too late, or throw myself into your arms and hang on for dear life. I've done both, at various times, and you've never once either walked away, or turned me away, regardless of the cost. And that's what I meant when I said I didn't deserve you." Scully's eyes burned with unshed tears. How had he gotten this far in his life, she wondered dimly, being so sure that the world would turn against him? To be so touchingly, heart-rendingly grateful for the simple human kindness and support of a friend, yet be so deeply certain that it would be taken away the instant he reached out for it? It was a good thing she had promised not to speak, because she wasn't sure she could push words past the emotion choking her throat. Give me a chance, Mulder, she thought fiercely. Give me half a chance and I'll love you so well, so thoroughly, that you won't know what hit you. "But tonight, when you tried to leave...God, Scully. All I could think was that I'd done it again. I'd hurt you again, and this time, I didn't do a damned thing. I hurt you *because* I didn't do a damned thing. I stopped you because I couldn't let you leave like that. Thinking what you were thinking. And the amazing thing was, you did. Stop, I mean. You'd just said this incredibly personal, intimate thing to me and I reacted like an ass. If it had been me, I would have been out the door so fast you wouldn't have seen me move. But you? Even though I'd been a jerk...and hell, I've been a jerk all along, why would you think that was suddenly going to change in the next five minutes...even then, you stayed, just because I asked. And that's when I figured it out. It happened. The blue streak of recognition, I think they call it. "Scully, I can't count the number of times I've sabotaged a good relationship before it ever began. I guess that's easier too...hurt them before they can hurt you, and all that. Or maybe it's just that the little hurt in the beginning is so much better than the big hurt later on. That way, when things don't work out, I can convince myself that I was never relationship material to begin with...that it was never meant to be...that I wasn't worthy." He chuckled again. "God, it sounds so pathetic. But it's true. It's amazing how well I know myself, when I put my mind to it." Scully couldn't take it anymore; she had to say something. "Mulder, you're so hard on yourself, and it's so unnecessary. You--" "Sh, Scully. I'm just getting to the good part." He crossed his arms over his chest, eyes dancing with sudden excitement. "See, I looked at you standing there, and I got it. Like a two by four across the back of the head, yeah, but I got it. You already know all that about me." For the first time that evening, a full, genuine smile spread across his face. "It blew me away. You can look at me and see all my bullshit for what it is. You see the man, the child, and deep in the darkness I carry around inside, you see the person I wish I could be. In my whole life, you're the only one that's been able to do that, or even wanted to try. There's almost no point to all the barriers I put up when you can destroy them with just one look." He grinned again. "You got my number, baby. God damn it, you know me." His voice softened to a whisper. "You...know...me." She blinked in amazement as his cryptic comments from the start of the evening finally fell into place. And with that knowledge, she finally understood the root of his fears...that she had fallen in love only with what he had chosen to show her. But now, the masks had fallen away, and he stood metaphorically and emotionally naked before her. The totality of his trust humbled her, and silently, she vowed that no matter what, she would never betray it. Never betray him. Once again he knelt before her, all mirth gone from his expressive eyes. "You believe in me," he said softly. "You know the truth about me, and still, you believe." He rested his cheek on her thigh. "I want to be worthy of that faith." "You are," she declared firmly, stroking his hair. "And you will be. No matter what."